In Other News

Product index

The pieces, at a glance.

Drag through the edit, then scroll through the argument.

Drag to browse · Click to read
The most literal ballerina · 03 OF 05Dries Van Noten · Leather Ballerina Sneakers

$880

After years of sneakers getting wider, thicker, and increasingly technical, designers seem determined to remove as much shoe as possible. Prada, Maison Margiela, Saint Laurent, Dries Van Noten, and Gucci are all selling some version of the same proposition: a soft leather upper, an extremely low profile, and just enough rubber underneath to call it a sneaker.

The result looks like a vintage runner that has been flattened into a ballet shoe. Slim racing shoes, indoor soccer sneakers, wrestling shoes, and track spikes have always existed. The Adidas Samba and Puma Speedcat already helped move fashion away from the swollen soles that dominated the previous decade. Ballet flats have been undergoing their own revival at the same time. These new shoes sit directly between those two movements: the familiarity of a runner with the delicacy of a flat.

They are, for lack of a better description, masculine ballerina sneakers.

How low can you go?

The new luxury sneaker is soft, low, and intentionally insubstantial. Prada and Saint Laurent reduce the runner until it begins to look like a leather slipper.

Black Prada Collapse leather sneaker in side profileShop new →

The purest expression

Prada

Collapse Leather Sneakers

The Collapse is the clearest expression of the idea. Its calfskin upper has elasticized sides, a removable leather insole, and a rubber sole measuring only seven millimeters. Prada is charging four figures for a shoe whose primary visual achievement is appearing to have almost no structure at all.

That fragility is what makes it appealing. The leather wrinkles, the sole nearly disappears, and the shoe follows the shape of the foot instead of constructing a new one around it. It looks more like something designed for movement than protection.

$1,150Retail
Shop NewSearch eBay
Black Saint Laurent Lewis leather sneakerShop new →

The cleanest

Saint Laurent

Lewis Sneakers

The Lewis pushes the same idea toward rock-star minimalism. It has grained leather, an elasticized heel, and what Saint Laurent calls a supple sole. It is essentially a black leather slipper with laces.

The lack of interruption makes it the easiest version to wear, but also the hardest to distinguish once the branding disappears.

$850Retail
Shop NewSearch eBay

When a sneaker becomes a flat

Dries calls it a ballerina. Gucci starts with a driving shoe. Both reveal how far the category has moved from traditional athletic footwear.

Black Dries Van Noten leather ballerina sneakerShop new →

The most literal ballerina

Dries Van Noten

Leather Ballerina Sneakers

Dries Van Noten does not pretend otherwise. The shoe is officially named after the ballet flat. Its snakeskin-printed calfskin upper, lambskin lining, and signature thin sole make it the dressiest of the group.

It looks less like a sneaker designed for running and more like a formal shoe that has been relieved of its responsibilities.

$880Retail
Shop NewSearch eBay
Black Gucci leather sneaker with driver soleShop new →

The weirdest hybrid

Gucci

Sneaker With Driver Sole

Gucci approaches the shape through the driving shoe. It combines aged leather, a slightly square toe, and a driver-inspired rubber sole measuring approximately 0.2 inches high.

It is probably the strangest hybrid here: part sneaker, part loafer, and part expensive hotel slipper.

$980Retail
Shop NewSearch eBay

Still a sneaker

Margiela keeps enough track-shoe construction to give the delicacy some resistance—and makes the strongest case that the shape can outlast the moment.

Black and white Maison Margiela SprintersShop new →

The winner

Maison Margiela

Sprinters

The Sprinter combines goat leather, calf leather, hairy suede, and a studded rubber sole. It still has the narrow stance and low 1.5-centimeter heel, but its layered construction gives it more substance than the others.

It looks like an actual track shoe remembered incorrectly—which is usually where Margiela is strongest. It wins because it still behaves like a sneaker.

$980Retail
Shop NewSearch eBay

Will they survive?

Thin does not automatically mean poorly made. All five use leather uppers and rubber soles, and Margiela’s layered construction should be more substantial than Prada’s deliberately collapsed shape. But none offers much separation between the foot and the street. The soles will wear visibly, soft leather will crease quickly, and the silhouette depends on the shoe looking slightly exhausted from the beginning.

That may be the point. People buying these shoes are not necessarily looking for the longest-lasting sneaker. They are buying a particular proportion at the exact moment it feels correct. If the shoe looks destroyed in a year, the owner may interpret that as patina. If the trend disappears in a year, durability may be irrelevant anyway.

The more interesting test is whether the shape survives after the logos stop doing the work. Remove the Prada triangle, Margiela stitches, and Gucci hardware, and the similarities become difficult to ignore.

For me, Margiela wins because the Sprinter still behaves like a sneaker. Prada comes second because the Collapse is the purest version of the idea. Saint Laurent is the cleanest. Dries is the most literal ballerina. Gucci is the weirdest.

Which one is your favorite—or are they all the same shoe?

Keep reading

The next issue, when it's ready.